The Tobermory Hotel

Just had dinner in the hotel restaurant. Must book for dinner, none residents after 8.15 pm. Creative and delicious menu choices, delightful staff. Enjoyable evening

The staff were excellent, friendly and helpful. However, the hostel is old and in need of refurbishment. It is cheap in comparison to other places to stay in Tobermory but I don't think it is good value. If you are a fan of the youth hostel experience then don't let me put you off.

Very clean, comfortable, food excellent and staff so friendly and helpful. Wehad very comfortable room overlooking the harbour. A view that couldn't have a price tag. The bathroom and bedroom were spotless. I would certainly return and would recommend to anyone.

I had dinner here 3 nights in a row. The food is full of flavour. Leo made me feel welcome as a line dinner and was on point with his service.

6 a pint and rude staff, diabolical for today's standards. Verbatim: "Hello, how are you?". No verbal reply. "Do you have any bitter?" "None" "Pink lemonade, please" Turns around. "Anything else?" "So that was there is no bitter?" "We close tomorrow, there's no point" It doesn't matter - if you are open be polite, explain the limitations and treat your customers well - they are paying for a service. Wouldn't stop here again.

Loved this hotel. Brilliant position right by the water. Our room was not huge but was so nicely decorated that it felt cosy rather than cramped. Bed was comfy. Good facilities with tea tray, dressing gowns, hairdryer etc. Bathroom modern with big shower. Unfortunately there was almost zero water pressure which was disappointing. We didn't eat dinner at the hotel, but breakfast was excellent.

The buffet was extensive with lots of fresh fruit, freshly baked pastries, small pots of delicious yogurt with fruit. The coffee was excellent. The cooked breakfast was good and the porridge was the nicest I have tasted in Scotland so far! The only thing I don't understand is the slightly bizarre range of reviews. I wonder if there is a'review war' happening in Tobermory, as lots of hotels and restaurants seem to have very bad reviews, often written by reviewers who have written very few other reviews (possibly fake accounts?) Don't be put off, this is a great place to stay.

Lousy restaurant. Can only talk about the food they served me. Very expensive, they try to make the place look posh but the food they serve is the worst I've eaten. I basically threw my money in the air and was left with a bad aftertaste. The hake fish was swimming in a ketchup soup liquid, the scallops tasted of nothing and the pinot grigio was the only time in my life that i could not drink it.

I think this place is a rip off that counts on the fact they will never see the same customers again. The staff was friendly and this is the only reason I reported how bad the food was after I had paid.

Had a really lovely meal in here. Seafood was very tasty and some really nice (and different) flavours added into the mix, stem ginger with scallops and tandoori sea bass, both delicious. Good staff, nice atmosphere would go again.

Had lovely fresh fish while looking over the bay. Exceptional service from the assistant manager. Anyone training in hospitality should visit and watch her at work! A delightful personality, aware of what is going on at all times and with local knowledge. Thank you for a perfect experience.

Non Resident visiting the restaurant. Callous and arrogant waiters - the waitresses were fine. My meal featured stale bread, rubbery seafood and sauce like sump oil. I love Mull and Tobermory but I will never return to this establishment.